| Platinum | Rocky River Coffee Co |
| Gold | My Sister's Place |
| Silver | S & I Ice Cream |
| Bronze | Abbott's Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Classy Scoops Ice Cream Lounge |
| Top Pick | Coffee & Cream |
| Top Pick | Desserts by Katrina |
| Top Pick | Johnny Roger's BBQ & Burgers |
| Top Pick | Papa Robb's Paradise Ice |
| Top Pick | Two Scoops Creamery Concord |