| Platinum | Afton Pub & Pizza |
| Gold | Johnny Roger's BBQ & Burgers |
| Gold | The Smoke Pit |
| Silver | Breakfastime Family House |
| Bronze | 2 Gals Kitchen |
| Bronze | Mykonos Grill |
| Top Pick | 44 Mills Kitchen & Tap |
| Top Pick | Afton Tavern |
| Top Pick | Mr C's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Not Just Franks |