| Platinum | Pier 51 Seafood Restaurant |
| Gold | Barcos Sports & Seafood |
| Silver | Krispy Krunchy Chicken |
| Bronze | Full Moon Oyster Bar & Seafood Kitchen-Concord |
| Top Pick | Crafty Crab Concord Inc |
| Top Pick | Mayflower Seafood Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar |