| Platinum | Gianni's Trattoria |
| Gold | Giovanni's Pizza & Pasta |
| Silver | Nonna's Pizza |
| Bronze | Basilico Italiano |
| Top Pick | Brooklyn's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Dimaggio's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Garofola's Italiano |
| Top Pick | I Bambini Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Isabela's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza |